Is there any leniency on the deadline?
- In order to ensure equal opportunity for all candidates, we enforce a strict deadline for the nomination letter and form. This is when applications must be received by Independent Sector. We ask that you do your best to ensure that mandatory letters of support are also submitted by this deadline. We accept emailed nominations until 11:59 p.m. ET on the day of the deadline. No extensions are granted.
How confidential is this process? Can you send me information on a nominee?
- Our policy is not to release nomination-related information to anyone other than the individual who submitted it. This is to protect nominators and supporters who provide this information to the Award Committee in confidence. Nominators receive a confirmation that IS has received their materials. IS does not contact the nominee during this process.
When does the committee decide on a winner? When can I expect to be notified?
- The committee announces its decision in late spring with a press release as well as an email to all nominators regarding the selection. Nominators are then responsible for notifying others who may have submitted letters of support for their candidate.
What if my nominee isn't chosen; can that person be reconsidered in future years?
- Committee members can choose to review nominations from past years. However, if you want to ensure that your candidate is reconsidered, it is best to re-nominate them.
Are there any restrictions on who can be nominated?
- Yes, the nominee must be living and be an American. He or she may be any age.
- The nominee's work must have national or international impact or, if at the regional level, has attracted wide recognition and imitation. If your nominee has local impact only, please contact your state nonprofit association, local United Way or regional volunteer center in order to get a list of local awards for which your candidate may be eligible.
- The nominee can not be on the Independent Sector Board of Directors, but can be a member of an IS committee.
- The nominee must be able to attend the award ceremony, which takes place at the Independent Sector National Conference.
- Please see more criteria here.
Once I submit an electronic nomination form, is the nomination complete?
- No, your nomination is only complete once you submit a nomination letter and three mandatory letters of support. The committee prefers that these letters not come from individuals representing the same organization as the nominee, but rather from persons who can offer a different perspective on the nominee’s work. Through their knowledge and experience, they can convey to the committee the transformative impact of the nominee. The nomination letter, mandatory letters of support, and optional letters of support may be submitted via email to firstname.lastname@example.org and should be limited to three (3) pages. Supplemental information is also helpful to the Award Committee. You may submit up to three (3) additional letters of support and up to 10 pages of other supporting materials (see below for details).
Who should the nomination come from?
- The nomination should come from someone who knows the candidate well and has the ability to convey to the award committee the impactful nature of their leadership recognize them as a an individual who has had a significant impact on advancing not only their own institutional interests, but also the broader interests of the charitable community. The committee values objective input; therefore, the nomination letter and letters of support should not come from someone representing the same organization as the nominee, such as an employee, supervisor, or board chair. Preferably, the nomination would come from a peer or partner of an unrelated organization who is highly familiar with the candidate's contributions and impact. Candidates are seldom self-nominated.
- If you submit your name as the nominator on the nomination form, the nomination letter should also be authored and signed by you.
- Please do not put an assistant's contact information on the nomination form.
What is the difference between a nominating letter and a letter of support?
- Nominating letters are mandatory and come from the initial nominator — the individual who fills out the nomination form. This letter addresses why the nominee deserves consideration for the Award (i.e. how this leader has been a builder, mobilizer, and unifier of people, institutions, or causes), and outlines the candidate's leadership record, past affiliations and achievements and rationale for being considered a transformational leader. It is preferable that nominating letters should not come from someone representing the same organization as the nominee.
- Three letters of support are mandatory and should be submitted in addition to the nomination letter to show the depth and breadth of the nominee's impact. These letters should each add something substantive to the nominee's profile. Limited to three (3) pages per letter, letters of support can be submitted via email. The varied perspectives they offer can help highlight for the committee the nominee's unique achievements. As with the nomination letter, it is preferable that mandatory letters of support not come from someone representing the same organization as the nominee.
- Additional letters of support are optional and may be submitted in addition to the nomination letter and mandatory letters of support to show the depth and breadth of the nominee's impact. These letters should each add something substantive to the nominee's profile. Up to three (3) letters, limited to three (3) pages per letter, can be submitted via email in addition to the three (3) mandatory letters of support described above. Additional letters of support are not required, and it is better to have fewer supporters who know the candidate well and can speak to their work in an articulate and persuasive manner, than multiple letters with little new to add.
- Nomination letters and letters of support can be sent directly to Independent Sector.
- It is not necessary to send all pieces of a nomination together.
What should a nominating letter include? Is there a word/page limit?
- Nominating letters should be no longer than three (3) pages and address why the nominee deserves consideration for the award (i.e. how this leader has been a builder, mobilizer, and unifier of people, institutions, or causes), and outline the candidate's leadership record, past affiliations and achievements and rationale for being considered a transformational leader
- Please be sure to sign all letters before submitting them as PDF attachments. If a supporting submission is in the form of an email, we will accept electronic signatures or ask that the email come directly from the inbox of the originator, in order to ensure authenticity of the letter. Letters should be designated from an individual, not an organization.
Who should I address letters to?
- Please address letters to the John W. Gardner Leadership Award Committee.
What additional materials are helpful for the selection committee? How much should I send?
- Biographical information, photos, news stories, brief writings, reports, etc., are all useful items if you believe this information will add something new to the nominee's profile. Resumes/CVs in excess of 10 pages will not be copied in their entirety.
Can I send videos, CDs, or movie clips?
- We encourage you to send any and all supporting materials that you think best exemplify your nominee. However, multimedia materials will not be copied and distributed to each selection committee member initially. Please instead send links to these items. We will keep them in a master file and make them available upon the request of a committee member.
How should I present the supporting materials? Does visual appeal help?
- All materials will be copied in black and white before they are disseminated to each selection committee member. Therefore, color photos or documents will not be transferable. In order to reproduce materials, they might be reordered, so please label all items clearly.